The Secret Language of Comics

Reflection: Tracing Pages

The process of tracing the two pages for Symbols: WHAT DOES THIS MEAN was demanding. It took a long time for me to decide what specific page I would like to trace and analyze. I also thought that the assignment would have been easier if I could refer to more than just a single page and explore it together. Especially for Stitches, which had many pages that symbolized David’s status, it made it hard for me to choose one. When I was tracing the selected pages and scanning them, I was not sure what the problem was, but it became blurry, which was a thing that I didn’t expect. I got to think about the secret language of comics, focus on the details of the authors, and analyze the purpose of using such drawings. I think it was the process of analyzing the page for a long time that allowed me to think about the secret language of the author naturally. It took some time for me to make my thesis statement in the ABT format, but it was interesting to write a thesis statement in the last paragraph. Also, during the process of tracing, annotating, and analyzing these pages, I learned that comics are not something just for kids and superheroes but can be profound as a book and be highly descriptive as a poem.

Reflection: Tracing Pages

The process of tracing and annotating allows me to dive into the images and recognize the details that got ignored when I was reading the comics at a normal pace. For instance, it allows me to realize the effort Bechdel put into depicting all the details of surroundings in her room: the clothes in the closet, the curtain beside the desk, or even the labels on the cupboard boxes, all of which contribute to enhance a sense of realism. The details also reflect lots of unobvious contrasts: like the different dressing styles of mother and daughter which are reflective of their diverging personalities. For Stitches, it made me notice that the author employed different shades of grey intentionally to emphasize his feelings of depression through the use of shadows on certain areas. Through shadows, he’s actually creating different lighting effects that help to establish the atmosphere.

Initially, I was struggling to organize my ideas into an ABT structure because all the patterns I was planning to analyze point to one general conclusion, so it may easily become an essay with three parallel body paragraphs. So I spent some time reorganizing my thoughts, trying to find if there exists a progressive argument that allows me to gradually dive deeper into my analysis instead of presenting a general rule in the opening paragraph and using all the other paragraphs to prove it. Eventually, I decided to have two body paragraphs, one on visuals and the other on texts, but I will save my concluding remarks to the end which enables me to gradually unfold my arguments.

The title of my essay is “the hidden storyteller”, which resonates well with the focus of the course “secret language of comics.” The process of slowing down and reading one page for several times significantly enhanced my understanding of the comics, and it was during the process of writing about them and comparing the two comics that I was able to notice the patterns I ignored. For instance, after I decided to focus on the representation of emotions in both comics, I began to notice the various ways employed by the two authors that are reflective of how they dealt with emotions. Especially for Fun Home, it was through comparing it with Stitches that I realized how emotionally detached it is. It feels like a documentary of the past, and the narrator is trying to explain it, interpret it, and reflect on it by analyzing herself. On the other hand, Stitches is sentimental, passionate, the emotions are powerful.

Reflection: Tracing Pages

My thesis was: Allison Bechdel and David Small analyze their parents’ life and visually portray their views of their parents but the reality of these situations is very unclear because it is all one perspective. Therefore, some stories are never fully understood, no matter how hard one digs and asks. No one can really understand another persons life without actually living it.

This assignment was pretty tough. I think that I made it hard on myself by choosing pages that were difficult to find similarities in. The tracing portion of this assignment was interesting because I did tend to think more about what is happening on the picture, relying more on what I saw rather than what I was being told. I was able to understand both texts better because of this. Coming up with an ABT thesis was a long process for me and the structure of the paper wasn’t relatively hard. I will say that it was rather confusing trying to combine everything and making it make sense.

I think that through this process I do understand the advantages of using a comic can have. I also began to see them as being more than just a superhero thing. Fun Home and Stitches were easier to understand the more I began to synthesize the pages. I realized that I was really only reading to know what they were talking about. I think that I began to see more of the resemblances and differences of these texts, such as how they both dealt with stubborn parents, death, and hardships of sexuality, but are very different people.

Writing A Bad Dad

The process of writing and compiling my tracing pages assignment, A Bad Dad, was demanding. It had been a while since I last traced anything for any reason, nonetheless a comic book page that I was going to critically analyze. But frankly, I found that I enjoyed that particular holdover from arts and crafts. The actual process of tracing was peaceful, and I didn’t mind annotating as we have been thinking about the comics format for several weeks now. My troubles arose from structuring a thesis and an essay. The ABT thesis format was new to me, and I am not sure I crafted the strongest thesis. Although I don’t think my topic is terrible, I think if I had tackled this project sooner I might have been able to do better. I attempted to grapple with the moral compositions of the fathers in Stitches and Fun Home, arguing that on both the pages I selected to analyze, they were acknowledging their own shortcoming, though Bruce Bechdel does so more implicitly as he struggles to fully acknowledge the life he has lead. I think this project has made me appreciate the subtleties of comics, and I look forward to engaging with more interesting books this semester.

Tracing Stitches and Fun Home

Tracing Pages – Reflection Post

My essay’s thesis: Both David Small and Alison Bechdel reveal the homosexual nature of their mother and father respectively in a sudden manner and do so through different artistic and literary means, but utilizing these two aspects of their pages, and pairing it with the medium of comics allows for both authors to convey their greater message; therefore, by analyzing the common patterns in both pages, it can be surmised that Small and Bechdel do all of this to share with readers the shock that both authors experienced with the reveal of their parents’ secret homosexuality.

Before writing my essay, the actual tracing of the pages was an important step. I used to trace images from the internet quite often as a kid and this truly brought me back. Tracing the pages allowed me to notice details about the different panels, but more importantly, gave me time to ruminate on the hidden messages on each page. Ideas such as the commonality in the shock of each authors’ reveal and why each author felt the need to do so came to me while I traced each page.

Writing in the ABT format was new and quite frankly tough. It forced me to carefully choose my pages and the subsequent characteristics of each page. I felt my essay made a leap (which is why I repeatedly include words such as “surmise,” “can,” and “likely,”) as the larger message that I claim the authors are making are purely my interpretations of the evidence provided on each page.

But I feel that I am not in the wrong for making an ideological leap. The focus of this essay was focusing on the “secret language” that Bechdel and Small are attempting to communicate in. Only the authors know the answers to why they made the climactic reveal so shocking, but it is the job of analytical readers to make realistic claims that are heavily implied by what we see on the page.

Assignment link

Tracing Pages Reflection

After completing my tracing pages assignment, I can say that I learned a lot about the process of writing an unconventional essay. By beginning with the tracing assignment I was able to view the text that I was going to be writing about in a different light. Not only did actually tracing the pages help me draft ideas for my essay, so did writing the annotations and really taking the time to understand the intentions of the two authors. I was definitely surprised to see that we were expected to have our thesis statement at the end of the essay. This was never something that I had done before but I thought it was interesting how the whole essay works up to that point of clarity and final explanation of what you had been writing about. I feel like I understand both books better as well as the internal thoughts of each author as they were crafting their comics. The single biggest insight that I gained about the two books would be how difficult it must have been to format and create a narrative that accurately explains what each author experienced as a child. Overall, I found this assignment to be very unique, interesting, and eye-opening.

My thesis for this essay is: The comics Stitches by David Small and Fun Home by Alison Bechdel focus on the complicated relationship between a child and their emotionally distraught parent but each story is separated by the families’ struggles as well as concerns, therefore, highlighting the individuality and complexity of one’s connection to their parents. In my essay I focus on the differences between Small and Bechdel’s relationship with their parents and how their households differed.

LN Reflection

When writing this narrative, it wasn’t too hard to think of memories of reading or writing because that is what I spent most of my childhood anyways. I never realized how reading in general effected me but especially the memory of the school library room. It did not feel strange having to free write because that my go to writing method but I had to go back and make sure I included core details that were necessary to the memory. Looking back, I know I was always reading but it surprised me that when I reflected on why it didn’t click in my brain that it was because I was an only child and books introduced me to a new world. The most interesting sentence from my narrative would be “As a child you become so curious about the world and books provide a lot of insight and new ideas for the hound mind to store and interpret in their own way.” Most children are taught through videos or being on their iPad and its honestly sad to me that a lot of children have lost the amazing opportunity reading brings, to expand your knowledge and imagination.

The Link to it: https://comiccommotion.wordpress.com/literacy-narrative/

Ethan Cohen – Reflection on Tracing Stitches and Fun Home

My essay was about how both Allison Bechdel and David Small employ several similar stylistic strategies as well as similar thematic ideas, but have varying ways of depicting such, therefore we can conclude that there is no clear cut best way to express oneself through comics. The two show the weirdness of time as well as all-at-onceness through showing four David’s sliding down a tube, or as Allison depicts showing scenes depicting different moments in time all sanctioned as one. Allison resorts to more word heavy, clear cut observations within each panel, while David takes advantage of the freeing art of abstract expression of real ideas through his panels’ images.

The process of tracing the pages as a brainstorming analysis, was a helpful and rich process for me. It inspired closer reading than most would gather from either page, and the act of comparing one to another made it that much more fruitful, especially implementing the works of Hilary Chute as an argumentative backbone. As I was drawing, I was in close attention to the style of everything: the furniture, the emotions on the faces of the characters, to the flow of the page more literally. This was useful for me, as it forced me to interact closely with the text.

Typically, I have started with theses in the introductory paragraph. Some of my strongest writing has sprouted from me writing the introductory paragraph last, even after the conclusion. Thus, having the last paragraph functionally operate as the typical introduction, this was a very natural writing process for me, that felt much more established.

Although my overall argument was how Allison employs less secret language strategies on the surface level, I was surprised how many intricacies she is able to accomplish through the a semi-typical comic structure, such as the framing and literal drawing elements that help to convey something that otherwise would not be possible under a captured photograph or a written work, in addition to how ever-present Chute’s all-at-onceness as well as fragmenting of time is in the totality of every page and panel: it is truly a conscious and important decision to be implemented into every successful comic.

Literacy Narrative: Part 1 Reflection

After reading the instructions, I thought it would be easy as I considered myself to have more episodes regarding learning languages as a bilingual. I first believed that it could not be harder than the pre-writing task where I had to force myself to narrow down my experiences. However, unlike what I expected, the assignment was difficult. The past memories of learning English were engraved into my brain, making it almost impossible to summarize and filter them out. Hence, I chose 3 major ways that shaped my language and introduced them with the stories of how I obtained them. Starting from the anecdote of when I was illiterate, I explain how I started reading novels in Canada, how I started making vocabulary lists, and how I was able to apply all these – new grammar structure, vocabulary, and phrase – and made them my own in high school.

As some events that shaped my current reading and writing skills have a causal relationship with one another, I wrote in chronological order. The method of storytelling helps a smoother understanding of how and why I obtained the specific methods.

The assignment was an opportunity to think about how I developed my current reading and writing skills. It was interesting to organize the history while remembering the painful but worthful past of learning English. Also, by looking back at the time when I could not fluently express my thoughts, I once again felt the aspect of language that liberates people.

Reflection Literacy Narrative 1

I thought this narrative was very different because I had never written about my experiences regarding writing and reading. I always had a specific topic in mind hence this exercise was a bit different from me. I thought the free writing exercise helped facilitate the flow of ideas in my mind and helped me explore different aspects that I could write about. By the end of the narrative, I realized that this memory which initially did not seem that important was one that stuck with me. In the process of writing this essay I realized that I must work more on my writing skills to effectively communicate and put my ideas forth. A sentence I think people would identify with the most would be “It was just an ordinary day where I decided to read a regular book and take a break from everything else.” The simplicity of this statement makes it interesting because it is so routine that no one realizes how important moments like these are.

css.php