Tracing of Stitches
Stitches, p216&217

ENGRD101.24. Spring 2022. Emory University
Stitches, p216&217

Fun Home, p158

The process of writing and compiling my tracing pages assignment, A Bad Dad, was demanding. It had been a while since I last traced anything for any reason, nonetheless a comic book page that I was going to critically analyze. But frankly, I found that I enjoyed that particular holdover from arts and crafts. The actual process of tracing was peaceful, and I didn’t mind annotating as we have been thinking about the comics format for several weeks now. My troubles arose from structuring a thesis and an essay. The ABT thesis format was new to me, and I am not sure I crafted the strongest thesis. Although I don’t think my topic is terrible, I think if I had tackled this project sooner I might have been able to do better. I attempted to grapple with the moral compositions of the fathers in Stitches and Fun Home, arguing that on both the pages I selected to analyze, they were acknowledging their own shortcoming, though Bruce Bechdel does so more implicitly as he struggles to fully acknowledge the life he has lead. I think this project has made me appreciate the subtleties of comics, and I look forward to engaging with more interesting books this semester.
The two canonical graphic narratives – Alison Bechdel’s Fun Home and David Small’s Stitches – both investigated real childhood trauma through extraordinary comic techniques. Several common stylistic elements are employed along with significant differences, leading to a deeper insight into the thematic core of the two masterpieces. In this essay page 286 of Stitches and page 123 of Fun Home would be explored in detail, both pages showcased the authors’ interaction with his/her father, pointing to the deepest source of their traumatic experience. First, both pages of comics utilized the strongest weapon of comics – “choreograph and shape time” by “arranging pace on the page in panels”, using Hilary Chute’s words. In page 286 of Stitches, the first row had two smaller boxes showing father detachedly and aggressively telling small David the truth that he had given him cancer; the next small box demonstrates David’s numbed face with no reaction, but then followed by two large panels displaying fathers’ face, then David’s astonished, frightened facial expression, while his fingertips touching the “growth” on the neck. The large panels without comment or dialogue “frozen” time for David as well as for the reader to accept the cruel fact that the source of David’s trauma – parental emotional abuse and medical disease – is interconnected. On the other hand, the Fun Home page had an enormous panel (about 2/3 of the page) illustrating Alison’s dream hiking with her father. The focal point of the image is the sunset, surrounded by the heavily emphasized lining of woods; Alison was pictured at the corner of the image pointing to the sunset, inviting Dad to come uphill and appreciate the scenery with her. The disproportionately large size of a single panel also slows down the reader’s time as a reader would take a while to read off the woods, words, details, and symbolism. Interestingly, although the reader may read elements on this panel in a certain order, the positivity conveyed by the “sunset scenery” of the entire page would come in the first moment, known as the “symphonic effect” in Hilary Chute’s words.

Furthermore, the two authors had different rhetorical situations in terms of purpose and narration. David’s linear narrative begins from childhood and ends in adulthood since his trauma is deeply linked with his medical conditions and unfolding secrets over time; however, Alison recollects instances from different stages of her life and embedded texts and commentaries from various periods, thus constructing a “labyrinth” of time into the core of the story. Meanwhile, Alison’s commentary-dense literary style shaped the reader’s perspective to that similar to hers, but Stitches, having less comment, was more open for interpretations and perspectives. Moreover, the purpose of page 286 of Stitches is to express small David’s fear and astonishment realizing he was sentenced to cancer by his own father, hence emphasized on delineating facial expressions rather than the environment; however, Alison’s purpose on page 123 is to demonstrate her cure of trauma and what she wished Bruce had done, via the symbolism of sunset only she had seen.

Therefore, although Fun Home and Stitches’ theme is childhood traumatic experience relating to bad parenting and emotional abuse, the core, and resolution of trauma and authors’ rhetorical situations are distinct: David intends to linearly unfold his growth and the secrets in order for readers to empathize with his fear, escapism, and helplessness; Alison gradually resolved the trauma over her discovery of homosexuality by investigating into her father’s sexuality and spiritual world, finally resonated with his situation and related to him. Such distinct core ideas and purposes of two literary drawings resulted in the stylistic and literary differences in each of traced pages, making comics a unique, empowering way to express authors’ intimate and sincere feelings and experience.
Citation:
1. Chute, Hillary. Comics for Grown-ups? from Why Comics?: From Underground to Everywhere. HarperCollins Publishers, New York, 2017.
Annotated Pages:
Reflection Post:
My analysis starts from examining page 286 of Stitches and page 123 of Fun Home, leading to a comparison of rhetorical situations and stylistic elements employed in two works, finally reflected on the core of two traumatic experience: Alison investigated her own homosexuality and resolved trauma by empathizing with her father, yet David exhibited traumatic experience of horrid emotional abuse and medical gaze from childhood.
It’s a calm, appreciating experience to trace pages with pencils. By really imitating the contours, lines, and other details on the tracing paper, I could intimately feel the power and detail of images created by two talented drawers, and meanwhile come up with comparisons of their work and thus deeper understanding of their message, which helped a lot to form the thesis idea.
This is the first time for me to write an ABT thesis, or any essay that start from simple observations and proceed to a larger claim. However, I realized this isn’t the first time I read such text – the first-rate maths/science textbook would also start off from motivations and examples, then proceed to proofs of more generalized statements. This is indeed a rather reader-friendly, heuristic way to write an essay.
Apart from aforementioned stylistic observations, I also noticed more interesting facts about each work: Fun Home employed spiraling timeline, but Stitches used rather linear progression; on the thematic level, Alison empathized with her father’s sexuality and pressure laid by heterosexual normativity, but David voluntarily chose to forgive his parents after many years and trouble. These elements combined definitely tell the “secret language of comics” that hides below the surface drawing of the first sight.
Annotated Pages:
My essay’s thesis: Both David Small and Alison Bechdel reveal the homosexual nature of their mother and father respectively in a sudden manner and do so through different artistic and literary means, but utilizing these two aspects of their pages, and pairing it with the medium of comics allows for both authors to convey their greater message; therefore, by analyzing the common patterns in both pages, it can be surmised that Small and Bechdel do all of this to share with readers the shock that both authors experienced with the reveal of their parents’ secret homosexuality.
Before writing my essay, the actual tracing of the pages was an important step. I used to trace images from the internet quite often as a kid and this truly brought me back. Tracing the pages allowed me to notice details about the different panels, but more importantly, gave me time to ruminate on the hidden messages on each page. Ideas such as the commonality in the shock of each authors’ reveal and why each author felt the need to do so came to me while I traced each page.
Writing in the ABT format was new and quite frankly tough. It forced me to carefully choose my pages and the subsequent characteristics of each page. I felt my essay made a leap (which is why I repeatedly include words such as “surmise,” “can,” and “likely,”) as the larger message that I claim the authors are making are purely my interpretations of the evidence provided on each page.
But I feel that I am not in the wrong for making an ideological leap. The focus of this essay was focusing on the “secret language” that Bechdel and Small are attempting to communicate in. Only the authors know the answers to why they made the climactic reveal so shocking, but it is the job of analytical readers to make realistic claims that are heavily implied by what we see on the page.
After completing my tracing pages assignment, I can say that I learned a lot about the process of writing an unconventional essay. By beginning with the tracing assignment I was able to view the text that I was going to be writing about in a different light. Not only did actually tracing the pages help me draft ideas for my essay, so did writing the annotations and really taking the time to understand the intentions of the two authors. I was definitely surprised to see that we were expected to have our thesis statement at the end of the essay. This was never something that I had done before but I thought it was interesting how the whole essay works up to that point of clarity and final explanation of what you had been writing about. I feel like I understand both books better as well as the internal thoughts of each author as they were crafting their comics. The single biggest insight that I gained about the two books would be how difficult it must have been to format and create a narrative that accurately explains what each author experienced as a child. Overall, I found this assignment to be very unique, interesting, and eye-opening.
My thesis for this essay is: The comics Stitches by David Small and Fun Home by Alison Bechdel focus on the complicated relationship between a child and their emotionally distraught parent but each story is separated by the families’ struggles as well as concerns, therefore, highlighting the individuality and complexity of one’s connection to their parents. In my essay I focus on the differences between Small and Bechdel’s relationship with their parents and how their households differed.


I decided to use these two images as they both tend to represent a great concept that can be analyzed. In both graphic memoirs, they depict what each certain action conveys to each of the family members. I interpreted as a way to maintain stability within the family.
To be honest, I feel like I could have done more with the essay if I had time to map out the concepts I have. I had a great start but I just feel as f it got weak as the essay progressed. I plan on revising it whenever I have time. But the link will be attached below !