Halfa Kucha Reflection
https://slides.com/jinjack/bold/embed
Link (if embedding isn’t working) https://slides.com/jinjack/bold
I chose to compare Stitches and Gender Queer inspired by Judith Hermann’s dialectic on trauma: there are both the will to proclaim and the will to not do so, and only the former will leads to recovery. I searched the comics read in the semester and spotted that these two works are distinct in artistic cues yet similar in the lens of Judith’s theory. Then, I parsed the contradiction in David’s situation and contrasted it with the quicker recovery of Maya, along with a detailed visual analysis accompanying theoretical framing.
I drew visual symbols for my arguments on visual analysis, which to me represents the spirit of this class – “draw to win”. I believed the main characteristics and shining aspects of images could be abstracted into symbols that are still recognizable, so I drew white blocks in the black ground to signify “blocks of time”. Employing visual devices for visual argument is fun, and that only happens when the medium of the rhetorical act is presentation, not writing. Hence, writing is different from multi-medium, live presentation in terms of the means of argument; I would definitely use more meticulous phrases – rather than images – to convey my point if I were to write an essay.
On great potential improvement is to present in a more natural language, then recite the script. In this project, I wrote the script before everything as if it’s an academic essay, then I found I couldn’t recite it. However, almost everybody on the first day presented naturally without reading the script, which would be more attractive than mine. In addition, Ali’s presentation related comics to our daily experience (of support systems), which invoked our relation to comic figures, rather than analyzing and observing them as objects – a great point I could pick up in future presentations.

































